Categories
Health

Trump repeats inaccurate claim about masks, citing CDC study. – NBC News

https://www.nbcnews.com/health/health-news/trump-repeats-inaccurate-claim-about-masks-citing-cdc-study-n1243562

The CDC report looked at 314 individuals who had Covid-19 symptoms and were subsequently checked for the virus; about half evaluated favorable. In a phone survey, participants were inquired about their social activities for the 2 weeks prior to screening positive, such as going to church, health clubs or stores. The scientists discovered that among those who tested favorable for the coronavirus, 85 percent had reported using masks constantly or typically. The study likewise discovered that for those in the group who had tested unfavorable, 89 percent had reported using masks with the very same frequency.
While Trump had the number right, the analysis of the information is unreliable, according to the CDCs report.

Follow NBC HEALTH on Twitter & & Facebook.

President Donald Trump is once again questioning the effectiveness of masks in protecting against catching the coronavirus. On Thursday, he repeated an inaccurate claim about masks, citing a current report from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
” Then you see CDC comes out with a declaration that 85 percent of individuals wearing masks capture it?” he told Fox Business anchor Stuart Varney on Thursday morning. “Whats that everything about?”

Dr. Todd Rice, lead author of the research study and associate professor of medicine at Vanderbilt University Medical Center in Nashville, told NBC News that the research study is really “mask neutral” and that the information wasnt designed to argue for or against mask using.
An essential problem with the “masks do not stop the spread” claim: The data was self-reported through phone surveys. In other words, individuals told the recruiters about their mask use; it wasnt observed through video tracking.
” You can picture that there may be some mistakes in the reporting of it,” Rice said.
Download the NBC News app for full coverage of the coronavirus break out

Individuals w/ and w/o #COVID 19 had high levels of mask use in public. Even for those who constantly wear a mask, there are activities where masks cant be worn, like eating or drinking. People w/ COVID-19 were more likely to have eaten in a dining establishment.– CDC (@CDCgov) October 14, 2020

Even for those who constantly wear a mask, there are activities where masks cant be worn, like consuming or drinking. The researchers discovered that amongst those who checked favorable for the coronavirus, 85 percent had reported wearing masks constantly or frequently. The study likewise discovered that for those in the group who had checked unfavorable, 89 percent had reported wearing masks with the same frequency.
They help, however theyre not a warranty that youre not going to get Covid if you use a mask,” said Rice.” There are some things that must be generally practiced, and that is the universal wearing of masks, avoiding crowds, keeping a range, doing things outdoors more than indoors and washing our hands often,” Fauci, the director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, informed NBC News Kate Snow recently.

While its appropriate to state that a big part of the individuals who tested favorable reported wearing a mask, the same held true for those who checked unfavorable, Rice said. The only conclusion that can be drawn is that most of individuals in the study reported using fabric face coverings or mask types “frequently” or “always” when in public.
In fact, the biggest risk element associated with Covid-19 was dining out, the research study discovered. Participants who tested favorable were twice as likely to have reported dining at a dining establishment, where mask wearing becomes challenging.
” Even for those who report always using a mask, it is crucial to consider that there are neighborhood activities where masks can not be used,” a CDC spokesperson stated in a statement. “People who go to dining establishments can not wear masks effectively while drinking and eating, whereas consumers can constantly wear masks when shopping or during other indoor activities.”
The CDC assistance on masks states wearing a mask is planned to secure other individuals in case the mask user is contaminated. “At no time has CDC guidance suggested that masks were planned to secure the users,” the agency representative said in the declaration.

Akshay Syal is a medical fellow with the NBC News Health and Medical Unit..

Masks shouldnt be believed of as the only method to avoid the spread of the coronavirus.
” Masks arent ideal. They help, however theyre not an assurance that youre not going to get Covid if you wear a mask,” said Rice. “I dont believe masks give you the capability to be negligent in other elements of trying not to capture this.”
Its likewise what Dr. Anthony Fauci has duplicated for months.
” There are some things that ought to be generally practiced, and that is the universal using of masks, avoiding crowds, keeping a range, doing things outdoors more than indoors and cleaning our hands often,” Fauci, the director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, told NBC News Kate Snow just recently. “That does not matter who you are. Thats what you ought to be doing.”

Full coverage of the coronavirus break out
Trump was describing a Sept. 10 report from the CDC that found that eating in restaurants raised the threat of infection more than other social activities. The report has gone viral today on social media, with the claims that the firms mask guidance isnt avoiding people from getting sick. On Wednesday afternoon, the CDC tweeted that “the interpretation that more mask-wearers are getting infected compared to non-mask users is incorrect.”